not looking for an argument or anything, but this statement seems a little harsh. if you don't like the guy or his band or his music, that's fine. i think most would agree he is at least okay at writing songs. the first album alone is proof enough.
I didn't slag him off or anything... just said he isn't a good songwriter, i don't think this is harsh.
I do like their 1st album, and even the 2nd. But as i said, he doesn't know how to use his influences. Recently he's been copying his own old songs. For me this shows he is not a good songwriter, he might have been inspired at times, but i find him quite talentless i'm afraid. This is obvious a personal view from a person who's been listening to them since Supersonic, is not as if i was just ranting him for nothing.
I think we need Liam as much now as we did 9 years ago. Is he arrogant or just telling the truth
People shouldn't be arrogant doesn't matter how silly others around you are. Arrogance is stupidity in disguise. I'm not saying Chris Martin is cool or not, i don't even like Coldplay (i actually dislike them as well), but i wouldn't say anything bad about him as a person, only that his music is boring (e.g)
The world is a shitty place, being arrogant will only make it more difficult... anyway, that's what i think... sorry if my views on Noel and Liam offended any fan of the band, it wasn't my intention, honestly.